Remember me

The Best Point Guards in the NCAA (CBB 1)

December 7, 2010

            How much tolerance do you have for working gradually toward an answer?    I have a clear set of questions here:  Who is the best college point guard in the country?  Who is the second-best, and the third?   Who is the best center?   Who is the best power forward?

            I am a long, long way from having accurate answers to those questions; in fact, on my list of the best point guards in the country (below) I wouldn’t bet that there is anyone who should be listed among the 50 best point guards in the country.   I am working on the problem, but it will take me a long time to get there.   I can’t even really explain what I am trying to do in one article.   If you’re patient with me, I will try to explain it gradually over a period of several months.   You have to start somewhere, and this is where I am starting.

 

 

First

Last

Team

G

Min

FG%

FT%

Ast

TO

Stl

Pts

PPG

Opp

1

A.J.

ROMPZA

UCF

7

159

49%

64%

35

11

13

48

6.9

71.6

2

Angelo

JOHNSON

Southern Miss

6

190

41%

82%

38

10

8

49

8.2

69.4

3

Aaron

JOHNSON

UAB

9

315

34%

91%

74

32

14

100

11.1

71.3

4

Brock

YOUNG

East Carolina

8

177

48%

65%

35

17

3

77

9.6

66.6

5

Johnny

HIGGINS

Marshall

7

116

33%

82%

22

13

10

37

5.3

72.3

6

Jeffrey

FORBES

E Washington

7

246

40%

91%

17

14

9

96

13.7

79.0

7

Jordan

CALLAHAN

Tulane

7

215

43%

77%

33

18

10

80

11.4

67.4

8

Zamal

NIXON

Houston

9

280

39%

92%

40

23

21

66

7.3

72.3

9

DeAndre

Brown

La Tech

9

303

42%

78%

31

37

11

145

16.1

70.0

10

Joe

JACKSON

Memphis

7

176

44%

79%

30

25

6

85

12.1

66.7

11

Jeremiah

SAMARRIPPAS

SMU

9

278

41%

67%

34

17

11

65

7.2

66.9

12

Biko

Paris

Boston C

8

259

41%

79%

23

19

6

74

9.3

76.9

13

Broderick

GILCHREST

Idaho State

6

204

45%

88%

14

26

5

87

14.5

66.2

14

Ben

CHERRY

Tulane

7

161

28%

88%

10

10

5

32

4.6

67.4

15

Marcelis

Hansberry

La Monroe

9

174

29%

70%

18

17

7

33

3.7

75.0

 

            The category to the right is the quality of the team’s opposition, from the Sagarin ratings.   With any luck this is the beginning of a series of articles, which I will title CBB 1, CBB 2, CBB 3, etc. (College Basketball—1, College Basketball—2), so that those of you who aren’t interested in college basketball can just skip these articles. 

            A. J. Rompza is a 5-9, 155-pound junior who blogs (AJRompza.com).   He’s probably not the best point guard in the country, but he’s pretty good.

            Aaron Johnson (UAB) leads the nation in assists.

            Jeremiah Samarippas has a great name, particularly if he chooses to become a bullfighter. 

            What you can do to help me here is to feed me what information you may have about these players, by posting comments.   If I have someone identified as a point guard who is not, in fact, a point guard—which I will do, more than once—then let me know.   I’ll fix things, and we’ll work gradually toward a better set of answers.

 
 

COMMENTS (6 Comments, most recent shown first)

schoolshrink
Shouldn't the place to start be by identifying the projected one and dones that play for Duke, Kentucky, Michigan State, etc.?
12:56 AM Dec 9th
 
champ
This seems like a lot of fun, Bill! Look forward to more. Reminds me of a "hands" rating I came up with back in high school. John Stockton did very well - the stat combined field goal percentage, free throw percentage, assists to turnover ratio, steals, and blocks.
4:54 PM Dec 8th
 
metsfan17
I mean not one of the guys on your list would be in the top 50 in the nation. But I'll keep reading
3:56 PM Dec 8th
 
metsfan17
Not sure how Tulane can have 2 point guards. Especially one who is averaging 4.6 a game and has an assist/turnover ratio of 1. He might be the WORST PG in the nation. Right now, one would have to say that Kyrie Irving of Duke is probably the best PG in the nation. Scoop Jardine of Syracuse is also very good and though he hasn't played very well thus far, Kalin Lucas of Michigan State. I'm pretty sure that not one of these guys would be in the top 50.
3:55 PM Dec 8th
 
Trailbzr
May I ask why you've chosen THIS project?
If you're branching into basketball, there's ton of NBA play-by-play available free by internet that can be parsed similarly to retrosheet. If you're developing research tools, I suspect that's the better dataset to start with.
8:21 AM Dec 8th
 
Kev
Bill,
Bill,

Your categories might also include:

Assist/turnover ratio.

Rebounds: offensive, defensive (total too, if you wish.) Rebounding PGs (from Oscar to Kidd are invaluable.) No different in college. Little known fact: all-time Div. 1 record for rebounds is held by Tom Gola of LaSalle (Phila.) He was only about 6'5" (going from memory).

Personal Fouls. If they keep a top PG on the bench for significant minutes, his team will likely lose.

Does his team run or play 1/2-court offense?

Does his team defend primarily man-to-man or some type of zone?

I've given some thought to weighted values: (e.g., Stl over TO.)

Big job, big challenge. Good luck.

12:11 AM Dec 8th
 
 
©2024 Be Jolly, Inc. All Rights Reserved.|Powered by Sports Info Solutions|Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy