Best Defensive Players of the Decade (Part I)

February 19, 2013
 

In the last Stat of the Week, we kicked off our celebration of 10 years of Defensive Runs Saved analytics with a look back at the best defensive teams of the decade. This week we continue our retrospective with individual defenders, broken down by position. We’ll start with the middle infield: second basemen and shortstops.

First, here are the ten best second basemen of the last 10 years according to Defensive Runs Saved:

Most Defensive Runs Saved at 2B, 2003-2012
Player Innings DRS DRS/1000
Chase Utley 9,809 138 14
Mark Ellis 9,531 113 12
Orlando Hudson 10,440 99 9
Placido Polanco 7,489 69 9
Dustin Pedroia 7,312 62 8

 

Chase Utley has a 25-run lead on the second-place second baseman Mark Ellis. Given the similar number of innings played by Utley, Ellis and Orlando Hudson—the only other players within shouting distance of Utley in Runs Saved—Utley is the definitive champion. His defensive excellence is built predominantly on his range and positioning, and that, remarkably, has not declined substantially despite his degenerative knee condition. Utley has played at least 81 games each season since 2005, and he has never had fewer than eight Plus/Minus Runs Saved in one of those seasons.

Next, here are the ten best shortstops of the last 10 years according to Defensive Runs Saved:

Most Defensive Runs Saved at SS, 2003-2012
Player Innings DRS DRS/1000
Adam Everett 6,505 119 18
Jack Wilson 8,762 115 13
Brendan Ryan 4,608 91 20
Clint Barmes 4,907 77 16
Troy Tulowitzki 6,430 68 11

 

Compared to second base, shortstop is a little less differentiated at the top. Adam Everett beats out Jack Wilson by just four Runs Saved for first place. When you consider that Wilson played more than 2,000 extra innings in the time frame, Everett looks like a clear winner, but using that same criteria, Brendan Ryan makes a compelling case to be the best defensive shortstop. Ryan has 91 Runs Saved in 4,608 innings, a slightly better pace than Everett’s 119 Runs Saved in 6,505 innings. I’ll give Everett the nod, mostly because of timing. The 10 years of Defensive Runs Saved data happen to match his playing career nearly perfectly. Before it is all said and done, Ryan may have the better career defensive resume.

Our holistic Defensive Runs Saved metric is made up of several runs saved components. Two primary components of Defensive Runs Saved include the Plus/Minus System, which evaluates the range of fielders at every position except for catcher, and Good Fielding Plays and Defensive Misplays. Defensive Runs Saved for second basemen and shortstops also includes Double Play Runs Saved.

 
 

COMMENTS (3 Comments, most recent shown first)

ErnieSS
mvander, that's an interesting way of looking at it. And yes, if I were a GM 10 years ago, I'd prolly pick Wilson.

However, I think that what we're trying to find here is "who is the best fielding SS," not "who had the most value over time."
12:42 AM Feb 22nd
 
mvandermast
These are nice to see. I'd agree the Top 10 would be nice to see, too. :) Stuff happens.

"Adam Everett beats out Jack Wilson by just four Runs Saved for first place. When you consider that Wilson played more than 2,000 extra innings in the time frame, Everett looks like a clear winner..."

I'd say that means Wilson has had more defensive value than Everett over the period. The difference between Wilson and Everett is over 2,000 innings of shortstop play at an essentially average level. I would think that playing shortstop at an average level has plus value, not zero value.
12:06 PM Feb 20th
 
doncoffin
"Ten best," but youonly show the five best?
8:48 AM Feb 20th
 
 
©2019 Be Jolly, Inc. All Rights Reserved.|Web site design and development by Americaneagle.com|Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy