The Flat Bat Award 2016

December 1, 2016

The Flat Bat Award is given annually to the best bunter of the year. To determine the winner, we look at run value—run expectancy gained or lost—for both successful and unsuccessful sacrifice and bunt-for-hit attempts for each player. Last season’s co-champions Delino DeShields and Dee Gordon both had limited playing time in 2016, which opened the door to several potential first-time winners.

Here are the top 10 players in bunt run value in 2016:

Player Sac Bunts Failed Sac Bunts Bunt Hits Failed Bunt Hits Run Value
Cesar Hernandez 5 2 15 6 5.39
Adam Eaton 7 1 10 3 4.04
Carlos Gomez 3 0 9 4 3.29
Shawn O'Malley 1 0 9 4 3.18
Denard Span 6 0 6 0 2.96
Rougned Odor 0 0 9 5 2.92
Gerardo Parra 1 0 6 0 2.69
Michael Bourn 8 0 7 4 2.69
Marwin Gonzalez 6 0 9 8 2.63
Ezequiel Carrera 7 1 8 6 2.54


The winner of the Flat Bat Award for 2016 is Cesar Hernandez of the Philadelphia Phillies. Let’s walk through his run value calculation to give you a better idea of how this number is calculated.

First is the calculation for the bunt-for-hit attempts component. Over the last three seasons, a successful bunt hit increased a team’s run expectancy by 0.439 runs and a failed bunt-for-hit attempt cost teams an average of 0.206 runs. Hernandez had 15 successful and 6 failed bunt-for-hit attempts. Thus, his run value for this component is (15 * 0.439) - (6 * 0.206) = 5.349.

The sacrifice component of the run value for bunts is more complicated. Over the last three seasons, even a successful sacrifice bunt attempt cost teams an average of 0.171 runs. However, it does not make sense to penalize players for successfully sacrificing themselves as they did exactly what their managers asked them to do. Instead, we measure a player’s effectiveness with sacrifice attempts with a plus/minus approach.

Since 2013, players have been successful on their sacrifice attempts 68 percent of the time. The difference in run expectancy between a successful sacrifice attempt (-0.171 runs) and an unsuccessful attempt (-0.343 runs) is 0.172 runs. Therefore, to compare each player’s ability to successful sacrifice himself to an average bunter, we add (1 - 0.68) * 0.172 = 0.055 runs every time he successfully sacrifices himself and subtract 0.68 * 0.172 = 0.117 each time he fails. This way, players who succeed more than the average will create positive run expectancy and players who succeed less will create negative run expectancy. Hernandez had five successful sacrifice bunt attempts and two failed attempts giving him (5 * 0.055) - (2 * 0.117) = 0.041.

When we combine the run value for bunt-for-hit attempts (5.349) and sacrifice bunt attempts (0.041), we get the 5.39 that tops the above leaderboard. We can see that most of Hernandez’s run value comes from his bunt-for-hit attempts. In 2016, he led the league in overall number of attempts (21) and was successful 71 percent of the time.


COMMENTS (5 Comments, most recent shown first)

John, I was a huge fan of the old Baseball Scoreboard -- wish you'd bring them back. Could you please publish the list of Flat Bat winners from the past 15 years (i.e. since Baseball Scoreboard bit the dust)? Thanks
9:15 PM Dec 8th
If a batter attempts to bunt twice unsuccessfully and then hits away with two strikes (with whatever result), does this count as a SAC attempt?
5:21 AM Dec 3rd
What amazes me also is every one of these guys bats over .500 on his bunts for hits, but none of them bunt that much. I get that if in AL you don't try to bunt that much on Machado or Beltre, guys like that, but there are corner guys you can just bunt on a lot.
10:51 AM Dec 2nd
Anyone know how to find out how many bunts Brett Butler had in his career? It seems to me he bunted at a much higher frequency then today.

Always liked Adam Eaton because he reminds me of Butler.
10:46 AM Dec 2nd
The Phillies were in the newspapers last spring talking about using the Sac Bunt more--but didn't do it. They actually dropped off from 53 Sac Bunts to 46. Hernandez is a jewel, though. . .371 on base percentage and good defense at second base. He's kind of a Willie Randolph type.
5:42 PM Dec 1st
©2019 Be Jolly, Inc. All Rights Reserved.|Web site design and development by|Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy