Remember me

Who Are the Best Defensive Teams So Far?

May 3, 2012

Last week, we examined Miguel Cabrera’s move across the diamond to third base this year.  This week, we’ll expand our early-season defensive analysis to the team level.

Cabrera’s Tigers are the worst defensive team in the American League through the first month of the season.  Using Defensive Runs Saved, we estimate that poor fielding cost Detroit 19 runs through May 1.  The Tigers’ defense isn’t the worst in all of baseball, however.  That distinction belongs to the Colorado Rockies.  The Rockies porous defense has cost them 26 runs defensively through their first 23 games.  That’s nearly three games lost because of below-average defense!  Even three-time Fielding Bible Award winner Troy Tulowitzki (-5 Runs Saved) is struggling. 

Here are the five worst defenses in baseball so far:

Worst Defensive Teams - 2012

Team Runs Saved
Rockies -26
Tigers -19
Nationals -15
Mets -13
Brewers -12


On the other side of the spectrum, Team Canada, the Toronto Blue Jays, lead all of baseball with 31 Runs Saved as a team.  Toronto’s infield defense has been superb through the team’s 24 games and has saved the team an estimated 21 runs defensively. 

Here are the top five defenses so far:

Best Defensive Teams - 2012

Team Runs Saved
Blue Jays 31
Rays 23
Diamondbacks 14
Rangers 13
Twins 9


 
 
 

COMMENTS (5 Comments, most recent shown first)

dcmalinsky
To take the Washington example a step further, the Nationals have recorded outs on 73.6% of balls in play so far, which rates #5 in the Majors, and if pro-rated for a full season would have been #1 in all but one campaign from the last 10. Which means that for this defense to get back to "even" would require them to play defense at a truly historical level.
9:55 AM May 5th
 
yorobert
just reread that last post-kindly disregard.
1:09 PM May 4th
 
yorobert
i am trying to understand the implication of these fielding numbers. since washington has given up 39 less runs allowed than toronto (69 vs. 108), but their fielding has been 46 runs worse (-15 vs. +31), does that mean that toronto's pitching has essentially been superior to the nationals?
10:57 AM May 4th
 
those
And if they had the Blue Jays defense, apparently they could have "saved" 46 of the 68 runs they allowed, or 68 percent. That's also beyond unbelievable.
7:44 AM May 4th
 
TJNawrocki
The Nationals, who have given up the fewest runs and the fewest hits in the National League, also have the second-worst defense in the league? That doesn't really pass the smell test.

You have them at a negative 15 runs saved. So if they had just an average defense, the team would have allowed 15 fewer runs, or a total of just 53 over 24 games. That means their pitching staff would have a true runs allowed rate of 2.21 per game, which is, incidentally, better than the 1906 Cubs. I'm not buying it.
11:38 PM May 3rd
 
 
©2024 Be Jolly, Inc. All Rights Reserved.|Powered by Sports Info Solutions|Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy