Remember me

This Rivalry Stinks

July 12, 2008

 

I'm thirty-four years old. That means a couple of things. 

1 - I have a hard time staying awake past midnight.
2 - Life is less about fun and more about responsibility.
3 - I can no longer act like a kid unless-
4 - It's with my kids, and-
5 - I've been a Yankee fan for roughly thirty years.

Thirty years seems like a long time, but it's not. There are people who have been Yankee fans longer. They can wax poetic about Old Yankee Stadium, Mantle vs. Mays vs. the Duke, beating the Dodgers, DiMaggio's streak, when Scooter was an actual player and not a broadcaster. I can't compete with any of that.

 

The only thing I have in common with my older fellow Yankee fans is our collective hatred of the Red Sox. Sure, we all admire the numbers of retired Yankee greats and not-so-greats that adorns the left field wall at Yankee Stadium, a collection of some of the greatest names in baseball and some guys non-New Yorkers couldn't care less about. But we don't share in the same memories. Leyritz's homer in game four? How about Don Larsen's perfect game in the World Series? Buzz off, rookie...

 

We all hate the same uniform, though; a uniform that hasn't changed much over the last one hundred years, that's played in a home ballpark that opened conspicuously close to the maiden voyage of the Titanic and soon embarked on a title-less streak that lasted eighty-six years. We can't relate to the same players or even the same style game, but we can relate to the shared enemy: the Boston Red Sox.

 
So it saddens me to discover after DiMaggio and Williams, Fisk and Munson, Pedro and Zimmer, that the competitive fire, the bottomless pit of bile that resided in the stomachs of each of our fan-bases, has basically dried up.

 
The games don't mean what they used to. Yankee Stadium used to crackle with energy every time the Yankees and Red Sox played. "Boston Sucks!" chants were a dime a dozen, 1918 signs scattered generously throughout the stands.

 
Not anymore. Now, the players are friendly towards each other, cordial even. Watch anytime Derek Jeter or David Ortiz get on base. They practically hug it out with the infielder next to them, chatting about God knows what and where they're going to dinner that night. Last weekend, there were EIGHT hit batsmen.  After the game, all of the players conceded that none of them seemed to be intentional.  ARod was hit by a pitch square in the back earlier in the year. It wasn't intentional but that shouldn't matter. ARod makes $250 million. Thirty years ago, a Red Sox player would have found themselves on their backs the next inning.  

 
Not in the love fest that is now the Yankees - Red Sox "rivalry."

 
The whole dynamic between the Yankees and Red Sox has been ruined, mostly because the Red Sox took it upon themselves to win a few World Championships. It was a purely selfish act that did nothing for baseball except ruin the best rivalry in sports.

 
It was turning into an annual ritual. The Yankees would beat out the Red Sox for the division. They'd both make it into the playoffs due to the Wild Card and meet in the ALCS, where the Yankees would proceed to crush Red Sox Nations' dreams of ever attaining a world championship, whether it be in six games or the bottom of the eleventh inning when a knuckleballer gives up a homer to a mediocre infielder.

 
This little arrangement seemed to be working out for everyone. Boston was able to fester under its hatred of New York for being a bigger city and having better sports teams. New Englanders reveled in their disgust, wearing their angst and perennial disappointment like a badge of honor. Globe and Herald newspaper writers constantly reminded the masses that everything that could go wrong for a Boston team would, because Bostonians held the fatalistic belief that they were doomed to never win a championship again.

 
And then the 2004 playoffs happened.

 
Everything is different now. The Red Sox have won two World Series in four years. The Celtics are a force to be reckoned with while the Knicks are a punch line. New Englanders can now gloat where before they could only spew insults about how much better Nomar was than Jeter. The dynamic has changed. Boston has beaten New York. For now, Boston is on top.

At least the Patriots didn't go 19 - 0...

 

 

 

Scott Ham can be reached at scotth23@hotmail.com

 

 

 
 

COMMENTS (11 Comments, most recent shown first)

keving18
The Knicks have ALWAYS beena punchline while the Celtics have ALWAYS been a foce to be reckoned with.

So you can take comfort in the fact that some traditions are still being upheld.
4:57 PM Dec 4th
 
ScottHam
Conor,
If you read through some of the other comments, you'll see a discussion that addresses some of your thoughts
10:52 PM Oct 30th
 
vtek88
Hmmm, so the minute that the rivalry turns around and the Red Sox are on top, suddenly it doesn't mean anything anymore? Please. This sounds like the equivalent of, "Well, we never wanted to win anyway." Give me a break. Yankee fans have just been spoiled, and basically expect to make it to the post-season every year, and when it doesn't happen, suddenly it doesn't matter so much anymore. If that is truly the case, then you were never a die-hard fan to begin with. Maybe it'll take 86 years of not winning a championship before you realize how important it really is to you.
4:04 PM Oct 6th
 
scotth23
JeffSol,
I totally agree. I can't imagine what baseball fans out of market think when every weekend the Yankees and Red Sox play, they HAVE to be on FOX. They HAVE to be on ESPN. I'm a Yankee fan and it annoys me. How should fans in Chicago feel?

The rivalry was incredibly one sided for a very long time, which was really the point of the article. I don't consider myself a jaded Yankee fan. I try to be objective about what their budget means to the sport and to what effect it has had. Likewise, I like the approach that Cashman is taking in wanting the bring the budget down and build young talent. As a fan, it's much more rewarding to watch a player's career rather than the three years he happened to play for your team. I think it's better for the team and better for baseball.

The Yankees will always be despised by a good majority of the baseball population, including Red Sox Nation, and I understand the reasons why. If I hadn't been exposed to baseball around Chris Chambliss and Reggie, I might be a Mets fan right now. But it was put in my blood at an impressionable age and there's not much I can do about it now.

I do expect that if I ever bear Yankee fans that this site will let me know...
9:27 AM Jul 27th
 
jeffsol
As a New Yorker but a Met fan, my prespective is that calling Yankees-sox "the greatest rivalry in sports" is a bad joke that nobody other than Yankee or Sox fans ever agreed with. To begin with, as mentioned by an earlier commenter, over the last few years, for the first time, there actually IS a rivalry. 80 years of domination is not a rivalry, it's a lording over, and it was always more interesting to Yankee fans and Sox fans than anyone else.
As to what is the greatest rivalry? Hell, I don't know, and you probably don;t either, as fans tend to think the rivalry involving their team is the best. Among those I think could be considered would be Celtics-Lakers (recently rejoined), Giants-Dodgers (back in the day), Giants-Cowboys, Canadiens-Leafs, Rangers-Devils, Real Madrid-The World. Frankly, I think the greates rivalry in sports is almost certainly, at least in the US, a college rivalry, in that it's much more likely for two teams to both be consistently good in the same conference, plus the additional emotional ties. USC-UCLA, Kentucky-Lousiville, Harvard-Yale, Cal-Stanford, Oklahoma-Nebraska, Texas-Texas A&M, Tennessee-Auburn, Florida-FSU, just to name a few.
8:21 PM Jul 22nd
 
RyanTorres
In light of the "Papelbum"-gate thing I think we've seen how "evolved" this rivalry has become. As a Boston fan, I hope that we do eventually get this stink-y rivalry you lament mainly because no player needs batteries thrown at them from the bleachers, or their wife threatened in a parade or beaten up in a Cape Cod bar for wearing a Yankee hat. It wasn't nice losing to the New Jersey Giants, but there are still quite a few Giants fans here in New England. They used to be the closest geographic team in days before the AFC and the Pats and Jets. So here's to stinky-ness. The rivalry was always overblown anyway.
11:05 AM Jul 16th
 
scotth23
It was a tongue in cheek article from a "bitter" Yankee fan. Not to be taken very seriously. I think Red Sox fans might say that the rivalry has changed since the Sox have won two championships. The hate that existed between the two clubs certainly isn't there anymore, except for Joba and Youklis.
9:15 PM Jul 14th
 
dmcmurray
So when the Yankees dominated, you thought it was a great rivalry. But now that it is truly a rivalry for the first time in a while, you think it stinks. Hmmmm.
6:33 PM Jul 14th
 
Ron
This is comin from a 41 year Cub Fan. I think about right now the Red Sox think this is a great rivalry. Life is always better from the cat birds seat ! By the way I made the pilgrimage to Yankee Stadium, from Chicago this year. It was my first trip to New York. I flew in and out on the same day... It was a great experience.. I have to give it to New Yorkers, they know their baseball.. Boston doesn't have 26 time World Champs stamped on Fenway. Baseball and the Yankees....WOW

2:16 PM Jul 14th
 
DaveFleming
As a Boston fan, I like to think the rivalry is merely evolving. It's not that the rivalry stinks, it's just we lack, now, a clear 'frame' for the rivalry: it's no longer about the Yanks winning and the Sox breakin' hearts: that 80 year trend is over. Now we're at a point where we're trying to figure what the heck the rivalry is now about.
1:11 AM Jul 13th
 
Richie
Football now being more popular than baseball - sorry - doesn't the NEW YORK Giants knocking off the friggin' 18-and-0 Pats put NY back on top city sports-rivalry wise? Or is it really just a baseball rivalry between the 2 cities?
12:08 AM Jul 13th
 
 
©2024 Be Jolly, Inc. All Rights Reserved.|Powered by Sports Info Solutions|Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy