Remember me

NFL Week Five Review/Week Six Prediction

October 15, 2009

            OK, we did not have a good week.    In our first predictions of the NFL season last week, we agreed with the Las Vegas oddsmakers on 12 of 14 games.    When we agreed with Vegas, we were 7-5.   When we disagreed, we were 1-1.   Overall, we were right on 8 games (in terms of predicting the winner) and wrong on 6.    Vegas was the same.   However, in terms of predicting points scored, we were horrible.    My new system for predicting points scored in a game did not function well.   I don’t know what the exact count was, but. …wasn’t good.

            Let’s review first the ones we got right.   Minnesota at St. Louis, we predicted Minnesota winning 31-7.    It was actually 38-10, so that’s a very good prediction.   Tampa Bay at Philadelphia, we had the Eagles winning 39-14.   It was actually 33-14, so. ..can’t complain about that.    Indianapolis at the Titans. . ..we had the Colts winning 33-18, they actually won 31-9, so that’s OK.

            We had Arizona beating Houston 31-21; it was actually 28-21, so that’s better than one could reasonably expect.    Pittsburgh at Detroit, we had it 29-20 Pittsburgh; it was actually 28-20, one point off.     Dallas at Kansas City, we had it 28-20, Dallas; it was actually 26-20.   Those six games, we were right on the result, and pretty good on the score.

            Oakland at the Giants, we saw the Giants winning 27-12; they actually won 44-7, so. . ..it’s a win.   It’s a decisive win for the Giants and we predicted a decisive win for the Giants, but we’re not real close on the score.     Those are the seven games that our system predicted correctly and in concert with Las Vegas.     We also got the result right in one game that the underdog won—Denver over New England.  We had it Denver 15, New England 9; it was actually 20-17, so we were right on the result, although even there our point system was poor.   We had 24 points being scored, Las Vegas had 41, and it was actually 37.  

            Atlanta at San Francisco, we had the 49ers winning 29-10; it was actually 45-10 the other way, so that’s a ridiculously bad prediction.    Cincinnati at Baltimore, we had it Baltimore 27, Bengals 21; actually it was 17-14 the other way.  We were wrong on the result and wrong on the points.    Cleveland at Buffalo, we had Buffalo winning 27-21; it was actually Cleveland, 6-3, so we were wrong on the result and, again, worse than Vegas on the total points scored (Vegas had 40, we had 48, it was actually 9.)

            Jacksonville at Seattle, Las Vegas had the Jags winning by 3, we had the Jags winning by 4, but actually Seattle won by 41.    We couldn’t call that “close”, could we?   You don’t think?

The Monday night game was the Jets at the Dolphins.    Las Vegas had the Jets winning 20-17.  We had the Jets winning 13-7.   Actually, the Dolphins won 31-27.    Vegas was wrong on the outcome; we were wrong on the outcome and the over/under.

            Those five games we were wrong, but we at least agreed with the oddsmakers as to the outcome.   But Washington at Carolina, the oddsmakers had Carolina winning it 20-17—and they did.    20-17.   We had Washington winning it, 10-9.

            You may have heard, but did you realize that Washington through Week Six will not have played a team that has a win?    Week One they played the Giants.  Both teams, of course, were 0-0.   Week Two they played the Rams, who were 0-1.   Week Three the played the Lions, who were 0-2 (but beat Washington).    Week Four they played Tampa Bay, who was 0-3.    Week Five they played Carolina, also 0-3.    This week they will play Kansas City.   Kansas City is 0-5.

            And yet, as phenomenal as that is, Washington still has not played the weakest schedule in the league.  The Giants:

 

Strength of

Team

Schedule

Detroit

105.4

New England

105.0

Miami

104.6

 

 

Minnesota

94.3

Washington

91.0

NY Giants

89.8

 

            Detroit’s average opponent this year is more than two touchdowns better than the Giants’.

The Giants are about to be tested, though.   Washington should own that category by next week.   These are our updated NFL Power Ratings:

 

 

AFC

 

 

NFC

 

 

Team

Rank

 

Team

Rank

 

Indianapolis

113.3

 

New Orleans

118.9

 

Denver

108.4

 

Atlanta

111.2

 

New England

107.2

 

Chicago

108.1

 

NY Jets

106.6

 

Minnesota

107.9

 

Baltimore

106.1

 

NY Giants

106.2

 

Miami

105.4

 

Seattle

106.1

 

Cincinnati

105.1

 

Philadelphia

104.7

 

Pittsburgh

103.0

 

San Francisco

103.2

 

San Diego

99.3

 

Green Bay

103.0

 

Jacksonville

95.4

 

Dallas

101.0

 

Houston

93.8

 

Arizona

99.2

 

Buffalo

93.3

 

Detroit

93.2

 

Tennessee

91.9

 

Carolina

89.9

 

Cleveland

91.5

 

Washington

89.6

 

Kansas City

89.0

 

Tampa Bay

85.0

 

Oakland

83.6

 

St. Louis

80.0

 

            And this is how we see this week’s games shaping up:

 

 

Arizona

at

Seattle

 

Seattle

25

Arizona

16

 

Baltimore

at

Minnesota

 

Minnesota

25

Baltimore

21

 

Buffalo

at

NY Jets

 

NY Jets

25

Buffalo

10

 

Carolina

at

Tampa Bay

 

Carolina

22

Tampa Bay

19

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Chicago

at

Atlanta

 

Atlanta

23

Chicago

18

 

Cleveland

at

Pittsburgh

 

Pittsburgh

26

Cleveland

12

 

Denver

at

San Diego

 

Denver

24

San Diego

17

 

Detroit

at

Green Bay

 

Green Bay

32

Detroit

20

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Houston

at

Cincinnati

 

Cincinnati

29

Houston

16

 

Kansas City

at

Washington

 

Washington

19

Kansas City

16

 

NY Giants

at

New Orleans

 

New Orleans

32

NY Giants

17

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Philadelphia

at

Oakland

 

Philadelphia

31

Oakland

12

 

St. Louis

at

Jacksonville

 

Jacksonville

29

St. Louis

11

 

Tennessee

at

New England

 

New England

31

Tennessee

13

 

            At this point we appear to agree with Las Vegas on every game except one, and to be close on the point spreads on most of the games.    The one game we see differently is Denver at San Diego.   The oddsmakers have that San Diego, 24-20; we have it Denver, 24-17.   In terms of the spread, the biggest difference is in the marquee game, the Giants at New Orleans.   Most knowledgeable people think it will be close, and many think the Giants will win.   Our system, which doesn’t know anything except the scores of the games and that New Orleans is at home, thinks the Saints will win easily.  

            Over/unders. . .we’re mostly consistent with Las Vegas.  Here, let’s line it up:

G   A   M   E

 

We See

Vegas has

Arizona

at

Seattle

 

41 points

47

Baltimore

at

Minnesota

 

46 points

43.5

Buffalo

at

NY Jets

 

35 points

38

Carolina

at

Tampa Bay

 

41 points

40

Chicago

at

Atlanta

 

41 points

45.5

Cleveland

at

Pittsburgh

 

38 points

38

Denver

at

San Diego

 

41 points

44

Detroit

at

Green Bay

 

52 points

48

Houston

at

Cincinnati

 

45 points

45

Kansas City

at

Washington

 

35 points

37

NY Giants

at

New Orleans

 

49 points

47.5

Philadelphia

at

Oakland

 

43 points

40.5

St. Louis

at

Jacksonville

 

40 points

42.5

Tennessee

at

New England

 

44 points

43.5

 

            So we’re within four points on every game except Arizona at Seattle—they see it as a high-scoring game; we don’t—and Chicago at Atlanta (same thing).   Arizona has scored 85 points in four games and allowed 89, so I don’t see them as a high-scoring team.  Seattle has played five games, scored 115 and allowed only 82, so they certainly haven’t been a wide-open team this year.   The betting must be based on what Arizona did last year, maybe?

            These are the current temperatures of the 32 teams:

 

Team

Temp

 

 

Team

Temp

New Orleans

115

°

 

Dallas

74

°

Indianapolis

113

°

 

San Francisco

73

°

Atlanta

105

°

 

San Diego

71

°

Seattle

96

°

 

Arizona

69

°

New England

95

°

 

Houston

57

°

Minnesota

94

°

 

Jacksonville

52

°

Denver

94

°

 

Cleveland

51

°

NY Giants

93

°

 

Detroit

51

°

Chicago

93

°

 

Carolina

49

°

Miami

89

°

 

Buffalo

48

°

NY Jets

88

°

 

Tennessee

46

°

Baltimore

88

°

 

Kansas City

43

°

Cincinnati

87

°

 

Washington

42

°

Pittsburgh

82

°

 

Tampa Bay

32

°

Philadelphia

81

°

 

Oakland

21

°

Green Bay

78

°

 

St. Louis

14

°

 
 

COMMENTS (6 Comments, most recent shown first)

ventboys
Boy was I wrong about the Saints, at least for this week. I saw Brees have a pretty bad game against the Jets, and that slanted my judgement, plus I grossly underestimated the Saints' ability to negate the blitz offensively. I am still not completely sold on the Saints defense, but this game has to be called impressive. They got the turnovers against a team that takes pretty good care of the ball.
11:00 PM Oct 19th
 
ventboys
Bucholz Surfer, what a great screen name....

This year is going to continue to be one of the stranger ones that I remember. There are so many horrible teams, more than I can ever remember, and some really slanted schedules. I didn't know that NE had been playing all undefeated teams. Great stuff. This is the year for it.
4:47 AM Oct 17th
 
Kev
Saints' defense cannot hold Giants who will control the clock. Giants could break one to Smith. Only way NO wins is special team scores like kick returns, blocked kick and turnovers. NO needs a +2 in TO. New York has been a different team since Coughlin bit the bullet--more power to him.
2:01 AM Oct 17th
 
BuchholzSurfer
The Patriots schedule is the opposite of the Redskins: every team New England has played this year was undefeated when they met the Patriots.

This week, the Patriots face a winless team, Tennessee, so that'll be quite a change for them.

10:47 AM Oct 16th
 
ventboys
It's just intuition, but I am expecting this week to produce several upsets. There are several games that feature a "logical" favorite over a team that, for one reason or the other, is more likely than the norm to produce an emotionally "up" performance. A couple of examples:

-Baltimore has lost consecutive games due to late penalties, some of which might have been questionable. Their offense, after a good start, was gameplanned out by the Bengal defense last week. They are playing a team coming off of an easy game, who hasn't yet faced serious adversity this year.

-Tampa Bay changed QBs, and showed some life late in a loss to an outstanding team. They face a much easier task this week, at home against a struggling team. They have back class, having been 9-3 at one point last season.

I also believe that the Saints defense has something to prove this week. At home, coming off of a bye, but facing an experienced quarterback for the first time this year, this will be much more of a test than they have had yet. The Giants' road record is well known. Despite several leading indicaters favoring the Saints, my intuition favors the Giants, and possibly by double digits or more.


10:52 PM Oct 15th
 
Trailbzr
Yahoo! did an article this week about the Redskins' winless schedule. They said the random chance was one in 32,768, but they exaggerated by one factor of two. Their opponents had lost 14 games, the random chance of which is 1/16,384.

6:22 PM Oct 15th
 
 
©2024 Be Jolly, Inc. All Rights Reserved.|Powered by Sports Info Solutions|Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy